Has a player ever in the history of sports put up as many historical records as Jamaal Charles has in his three year career, and still be so unknown and so under the radar. Let’s take a look at what Jamaal Charles
has done so far in his short career.
In 2009, Jamaal Charles finished the season with the highest yards per carry in the league for anyone running back with 120 carries or over, and became the only player in NFL history to rush for 1,100 or more yards with 200 or fewer carries. He also became the only player in NFL history to take over as a starter halfway through the season and double the ypc of the player he replaced. Jamaal Charles averaged 5.9 ypc compared to Larry Johnson’s 2.9.
In 2010, Jamaal Charles averaged 6.38 ypc, which is the second highest ypc in history behind Jim Brown’s 6.4. He also become the only player in NFL history to finish second in the league in rushing yards and not even lead his own team in rushing attempts. Charles only had 230 attempts this past season compared to Jones’ 245 attempts. Despite Jones having more attempts, Jones only rushed for 896 yards this year compare to Charles 1496 yards, because Jones only averaged 3.7 ypc.
As of right now, Jamaal Charles has the highest career ypc for any running back in NFL history with a minimum of 200 carries.
What’s most amazing about Charles is that he defies the common assumption that an offensive line makes the running back. In most systems in the NFL, the ypc discrepancy between running backs on the same team is relatively close to each other. In the Last two years, Charles ypc compared to the other running backs on his team has been off the charts. His 3.0 ypc advantage in 2009 and his 2.7 ypc advantage in 2010 is proof that if a running back is great enough, he can make that much of a difference. Charles’ ypc advantage, considering how many carries he and his teammates have gotten, is something that we haven’t and may never see again.
From the moment I saw Charles play, I knew he had an amazing talent, and I even wrote an article after the 2009 season claiming that Jamaal Charles could be better than Titans RB Chris Johnson. At the time, most people laughed at me, and what’s scares is me is that if I wrote that now, they would still laugh. The question that needs to be answered however is why is Jamaal Charles still so under the radar?
The first obvious reason why he is underrated is because he plays in Kansas City. Players in Kansas City lack the exposure that big city players get and often get under-appreciated, which we saw in the hall of fame voting for the late great Derrick Thomas for many years, and most recently this year for Willie Roaf, who I could make a case for as the greatest offensive tackle ever.
However, playing in Kansas City is not the sole reason for this as his lack of carries, especially goal line carries, hurts his credentials. The reality is that with Jamaal Charles amazing ypc, a 2000 yard season or something close to that is very probable with more carries. A lot of fans and even experts overvalue yards in a season and undervalue yards per carry. Thus if Charles put up a more historical single season rushing yard mark, fans would quickly know who he is, just as they knew who Chris Johnson was after he ran for over 2000 yards.
The other reason is because Charles, who actually is a more efficient goal line rusher than Thomas Jones, isn’t given many goal line carries. Many fans and experts overvalue rushing touchdowns when the truth is that rushing touchdowns are often more of a production of opportunity and situation rather than anything else. If Charles was given more or even most of the goal line carries that most feature running backs get, his stats would be much more appealing and noticeable to everyone.
Sadly though, it doesn’t seem as though Chiefs Coach Todd Haley wants to give Charles a more featured role in the offense. One theory is that Haley is doing this to not ware out Charles, because of the tendency for running back’s careers to be shortened by an overload of carries as well as Haley wanting him to be fresh at the end of the season. But if Haley wants Charles to become that next great running back, he’s going to have to unleash him, and stop holding him back. Because at the end of the day, he’s only holding his team back.
Make sure you keep up to date with all the latest odds on the Arsenal
Football Club and back your favorite team in their upcoming fixtures.
Find some fantastic odds online today and if you’re feeling lucky then
why not also try winning on popular casino games such as online
blackjack, video poker and even basketball themed slots machines. No
longer do you need to wait for a casino to open or have one in your
local area. You can simply visit sites like LuckyNuggetCasino.com
from your laptop, tablet and mobile phone. Check their website today,
with free sign up and easy to download option and you can experience the
thrill of online casino games. Take advantage of free casino bonuses as
well as daily promotions and see if you can beat the dealer or other
challengers around the world.
As I sat there watching Kobe Bryant win his first championship without Shaq, I felt a sudden sadness. A sadness, that the game of basketball doesn’t usually cause.
It wasn’t the same sadness you get when your favorite team loses, but it was the type of sadness you get when you realize that justice isn’t going to be served.
As I watched Mark Jackson and Jeff Van Gundy at the end of the game infer that arguing about who is better between Kobe Bryant and Michael Jordan is a legitimate argument, that sadness grew even more.
It was obvious due to the talent the Lakers had that sooner or later Kobe would get his ring without Shaq, and I knew the aftermath that would occur. Since the NBA Finals, the Kobe-Jordan comparisons have not stopped, and let me tell everyone, it’s only going to get worse.
When I finally realized the game was out of reach, I went to my room sat down in utter silence and realized that the history of basketball had been changed.
Well The Kobe Bryant we see today is a much better player than Kobe Bryant who was on the Lakers during Shaq’s heydays.
Now that Kobe has won this title, people will forget this, and he may very well be in the mind of these so called “experts” such as Mark Jackson and Jeff Van Gundy elevated himself to one of the top five players of all time, if not higher.
He now has four titles, and because of his title without Shaq, Shaq’s legacy will only diminish and Bryant’s will grow as people start to forget who really led the Lakers to those first three titles.
Before I get into the details of why Kobe Bryant’s legacy should not be defined by this title, let me answer this one question first.
As I was reading an article about Kobe and Shaq, a question arose in the commentary.
“Why is it that no one questions the validity of the rings won by other stars that played with stars” (Besides Kobe)
The answer I read by, Michael T. Penn, could not have been any better. NBA betting lines.
“I think it is because most great second options aren’t hailed as the greatest thing since sliced bread like Kobe is. A lot of people love Kobe so much they want to talk about his three championships without even mentioning Shaq. That in turn leads others without the rose colored specs on to say ‘what? those were Shaq’s teams!’ That’s really all you’re looking at here.
It’s kind of like if someone were to turn around and say ‘Scottie Pippen is the best player ever because he won 6 rings’. Of course the rebuttal would be ‘Sorry but Scottie was second banana to Jordan, those were Jordan’s teams’. Then someone such as yourself may write an article about how even though Jordan was the man, Scottie was still a star. Like that clears up the issue.
Kobe was of course a great second option on those teams! The problem arises when people try to use those three rings as part of an argument to say Kobe is a better individual player than Lebron James or that he’s the greatest player not named Mike or other such over the top declarations of his unstoppableness”
On the next few pages, I’m going tell you exactly how a man with four NBA rings, who at times can be unstoppable, can really be considered overrated?To me Kobe Bryant has been overrated since he first entered the league.
When he first entered in 1997 towards the end of Michael Jordan’s career, the media and fans were looking for that next Michael Jordan. Kobe showed the flash and potential it could take to be the next one. He was immediately deemed the next Michael Jordan, a title that still sadly hasn’t faded away.
However, for you to truly understand why Kobe is overrated career wise, you have to realize what a person being overrated really means. Being overrated career wise, in a sense, means that a person’s career is perceived as being better than it really is. Down below I have listed the many reasons why Kobe Bryant has come to be overrated.
Before you read what I have to say, I just want to ask you one favor. Please read the rest of the article with an open mind, especially Lakers’ fans, or you will fail to see the truth.
Kobe Bryant Wasn’t As Big of a Factor As Perception Makes it Seem
Kobe Bryant, in reality, wasn’t as big as a factor with the Lakers during their championship runs as perception makes it seem.
If you took Shaq off the Lakers during their title runs, the Lakers wouldn’t be guaranteed to make the playoffs. When O’Neal was injured during his three peat, the Lakers had a regular-season record of 12-11 (.5217%).
When Kobe was injured, the Lakers regular season record was 25-7 (.78%). Interestingly, the Lakers’ entire regular-season record during their three-peats was 181-65 (.735%), which is a lower record than when Kobe wasn’t playing. The Lakers therefore actually had a better record when Kobe wasn’t playing.
But how could this be possible? Well as a big Lakers’ fan during their championship runs, I watched the games very closely. One thing I will tell you is that the team was at its best when the team played through Shaq.
The Lakers were most dangerous when the Lakers would play through Shaq, wait for him to get double teamed, and have players such as Rick Fox, Robert Horry, Kobe Bryant and Derek Fisher spot up for the open shot, or cut in the lane.
However, the Lakers often failed to play through Shaq enough, and it would cost them games sometimes. However, never was this more obvious than at times when Kobe would try to steal the show.
A young immature Kobe Bryant would constantly take difficult contested shots, instead of just playing through Shaq, then cutting into lane or spotting up for that open shot.
I‘ll admit that when Kobe Bryant was playing through Shaq, he was a great asset to have. Unfortunately for all the times he was an asset, he was also a cancer when he tried to be the “man”.
The Lakers’ record without Kobe and without Shaq is not a stat many people know of, as I couldn’t find it anywhere. I personally had to look at every game by game during the Lakers’ championship runs to find those stats out.
As I said earlier, I watched the Lakers very closely. One thing I noticed was that when Shaq was on the bench, the team frankly was just a mediocre team.
I also noticed that when Kobe was on the bench, the team was just as good without him. I therefore decided to do the research and find out if this was true or not.
Not coincidentally, the records I found proved my theory to be correct. As I showed earlier, the Lakers became a sub .500 team without Shaq, but had a better record without Kobe.
Bryant to me is one of the luckiest players of all time. Not many all time greats can say that they started their career playing with the best player in the NBA.
Every time Kobe looks at his first three rings, he should thank god everyday that he had the opportunity to play with Shaq. In reality the young Kobe Bryant who won three championships isn’t as good as the Kobe leading the Lakers right now.
The record books, unfortunately, will not have an asterisk that says “led by Shaq.” When Kobe is compared to the all time greats such as Michael Jordan, his first three championships to the naked eye will looks just as good as Michael Jordan’s first 3 championships.
If Kobe never played with Shaq, he likely would have one ring. Thus without most of his rings, Kobe wouldn’t be perceived to be the top five player of all time many perceive him to currently be.
Kobe Bryant is One of The Most Under-Performing Finals Player Ever
Kobe Bryant has shot 40.5 % or under in four out his six NBA Finals appearances (Around 36% in his first and 38% in his fourth appearance). How many all time greats have shot 40.5% or under once, let alone four times in the NBA Finals? Also keep in mind that in three of those four in which he shot that poorly, Shaq, not him, was the one being double teamed.
Kobe is perceived as one of the best clutch players of all time, yet on the biggest stage there is, Kobe consistently performs his worst.
In year 2000, during the regular season, Bryant averaged almost 29 points and five assists per game. How did these stats translate over to the NBA Finals? They lowered to 15 points and four assists per game.
Shaquille O’Neal, on the other hand, raised his scoring average, from 28 in the regular season to 38 in the finals.
In 2001, the Lakers once again won the NBA Finals. Kobe’s scoring average dropped in the clutch once again, forcing O’Neal to step up his scoring from 27 per game in the regular season to 33 in the finals.
In 2002, For the third straight year, Kobe’s scoring and assists declined in the series and O’Neal of course stepped it up in the finals.
Most greats like Shaq, Jordan and Duncan, all raised their level in the finals, but yet Kobe lowered his tremendously. Charles Barkley once said that stars are made in the regular season, but superstars are made in the playoffs.
Well, I would like to add on to that statement and say that stars are made in the regular season, superstars are made in the playoffs, but Legends are made in the NBA finals.
In his first three years, Kobe had the privilege of watching Shaq put up three of most dominant finals performances ever. In fact at the time of Shaq’s third championship, he was averaging the most points per game in NBA finals history. However, in Kobe’s last two NBA Finals, he cost his team the championship with his poor performances.
In the 2004 NBA Finals, Shaq averaged 26.6 points per game with a .631 field goal percentage, while Kobe Bryant averaged 22.6 points per game with a .381 field goal percentage.
However, the main reason Kobe cost the Lakers the title was that he out shot Shaq by nearly six shots despite Kobe shooting 38.1 %, while Shaq was shooting 63.1 %.
In that series, Kobe’s failure to play though Shaq hurt not only the team’s stats, but his own stats as well. Playing through Shaq more, would have helped his FGP and opened up more easy scoring opportunities.
Not to mention, logically, why should a player shooting with a much lower FGP average six more shots than a former three times finals MVP that was shooting a much higher percentage?
During the 2004 NBA Finals, Kobe decided that he was going to be the man, even if it cost the team. Not surprisingly, according to Phil Jackson‘s book “The Last Season: A Team in Search of Its Soul,” in Bryant’s exit interview with him Bryant said, “I’m tired of being a sidekick.” Shaq already had three Finals MVP’s and Kobe for once wanted that finals MVP.
Watch the tape of that series and you will see a mad man determined to be the “man,” despite the consequences the team would ultimately render.
In last year’s NBA finals against the Celtics with this time Kobe being the “man,” he again let his team down. Against the Celtics, he shot .405 from the field and averaged 3.83 turnovers a game. In fact, in three out of their four losses he shot under 35 % from the field.
Kobe all series seemed to start off playing well in the first quarter, and then fall off and never recover. Kobe is perceived to be the best closer in the game, but yet it seemed as though he often disappeared in the 4th quarters of last years finals.
In game four last year, Mark Jackson, a man who once said that Kobe Bryant will be better than Michael Jordan, even called out Kobe Bryant for not trying to take over the game in the 4th quarter.
I heard all of Kobe’s fans excuses last year. “His teammates didn’t show up,” “Kobe can’t be expected to do everything.” However, no matter what anyone wanted to say about Gasol, Odom, or any of the other Laker’s players, Kobe was the one who let his team down. If Kobe wants to take all the credit when his teams wins, he should also take all the credit when his team loses.
Now this year was easily Kobe’s best finals performance. Kobe led the team to the title and I can’t take any credit away from him. But even so, Kobe still underperformed in the NBA finals, as he shot 43 % from the field. If you at actually look at it, Kobe has had two good finals appearances out of six.
Although his numbers went down in the 2001 finals, he still played well as he shot .514 from the field. Then of course this year, despite Kobe’s FGP going down, Kobe led his team to a championship. Now two good finals out of six isn’t acceptable for a true all time great.
The true all time greats, like Jordan and Shaq, generally always showed up in the NBA finals, while Kobe has repeatedly failed to.
Kobe Is Still Compared To Michael Jordan
There are still people out there who claim that Kobe is as good as and or better than Jordan. I would dismiss these claims and not even mention it, except for the fact that there a large percentage of people who actually believe this.
Every time a Jordan Kobe debate starts there is always that one guy who claims that Kobe is better than Jordan. No matter what stats you pull out, that guy thinks he’s right and you’re wrong.
Now that Kobe has lead a team to a championship, this will only be more argued.
The Jordan – Kobe debate to me is one of the most lopsided sports debates that is frequently debated. If you look at it logically the question shouldn’t even be asked and on Page 3 I will show you why.
|Michael Jordan||Kobe Bryant|
|16 seasons||13 seasons|
|6 Championships||4 Championships|
|6 Finals MVPs||1 Finals MVP|
|10 Scoring Titles||2 Scoring Titles|
|1 Defensive Player Of The Year||0 Defensive Player Of The Year|
|5 MVPs||1 MVP|
Jordan has better career averages than Kobe in virtually every single category besides three point percentage
( Bryant: .341, Jordan: .327) and and FT % ( Bryant: .840, Jordan: .835). Kobe also has inferior playoff averages in virtually all statistics, and inferior career finals averages in virtually all statistics to Jordan. For those of who want to claim that Kobe’s stats are skewed because of his younger days from 18-21, (even though Jordan’s are too because of his Wizards days) look at this stat.
If you take an age by age comparison of Jordan and Kobe starting with the age of 22 to the age Kobe is now, Jordan has better stats in virtually every age by age category besides some years of free throw %, a couple years of BPG, some years of 3 point percentages, and the one year Kobe averaged 35.4 points per game.
Jordan also, besides free throw percentage (.868 to .857), has the higher single season high in every category. Plus Jordan never played with a player even close to an elite center, while Kobe has had Shaq and Gasol.
Kobe Bryant’s FGP Isn’t Up There With The All-Time Greats
One reason that goes under the radar for why Kobe Bryant is overrated is that his FGP is simply not up there with the greatest guards and small forwards of all time.
Kobe has a career average of a .455 FGP, while, obviously depending on your list, no other player generally considered one of top 20 players of all time has shot that poorly.
Julius Erving shot .506 , Magic Johnson shot .520, Oscar Robertson shot 485, Larry Bird shot .496, and Michael Jordan shot .497 for their career. Kobe has also shot worse than the two players playing today that will eventually make this list, if not for a drastic injury, Wade and LeBron.
LeBron has a career average of .471, which should go up as he gets older and Wade has a career average of .483. The main reason Kobe Bryant’s FGP is worse than Wade’s, Lebron’s, and Jordan’s, is that as good of player as Kobe is, he simply isn’t as good of an inside player as those players.
Kobe relies on his jumpshot more than these players and because of this his FGP is worse. This is especially noticeable when he plays against physical defenses, such as the Rockets this year or the Celtics last year.
Before game seven of the Rockets-Lakers series, ESPN showed that against the Rockets, only 21 percent of his shots were within five feet of the hoop. Now 21 percent just isn’t good enough, and that is one reason the undermanned Rockets took the Lakers to seven games.
As it often said, “you live by the jumpshot, you die by the jumpshot.” When Kobe isn’t driving the ball enough, this statement is never more true. Now Kobe is still a great inside player, but just read what his own coach Phil Jackson has said when comparing Kobe to Jordan in an interview in 2008.
“There are somethings that Michael Jordan had, that Kobe Bryant doesn’t have. He has a bigger body, He’s stronger. Kobe’s strong. He ( Jordan) had these incredible hands. Those hands were million dollar hands, where he could do so many things with it. Besides being fouled and still making baskets-Taking the ball to the basket and getting hit and not losing control of the basketball-Being able to pick the ball of the dribble.Those are just things that physically are irreplaceable….When you look at Michael, he shot 49, 50 %, and Kobe just hasn’t been able to do that. There’s a big difference when you compare those two. The shooting percentages were quite a bit different.”
Kobe’s Team Wins When He Doesn’t Shoot Too much.
If you were watching the pregame show before game seven of the Rockets-Lakers game, you would recall that Jon Barry showed a statistic that when Kobe Bryant shoots less than 21 shots, the Lakers were 39-3.
Up to that point he had taken 150 shots total in the previous 6 games against the Rockets. Now, can you remember there being a stat like that for a player considered as great as Kobe?
Is there a stat like that for Jordan? LeBron? Wade? Well, of course the answer is no. Not to the surprise of me and Jon Barry, the Lakers beat the Rockets in game seven with Kobe only scoring 15 points.
Kobe Doesn’t Have Any “Amazing Moments”
Kobe is consider one of the clutchest players in history but yet I can’t recall him having any meaningful amazing game winners. Now Kobe has had some winning go ahead baskets in the playoffs, but he has never had one of those “Jordanesque” moment that you can replay in your head over and over again.
If you have been watching a lot of NBA games this year, you would have noticed those amazing NBA moments commercials. Well the one Kobe Bryant moment that they keep showing over again is his game winning shot against the Suns a few years ago in the first round. Here’s my problem with it. The Lakers lost the series!
Is that really the best Kobe moment that they could find. Well, sadly it could be. On the other hand, I can point out to a few plays that LeBron James has made in the playoffs in his career, that would have been better amazing moments, and sadly he is much younger than Kobe.
In reality, during the Lakers’ championship run, it was Derek Fisher, Robert Horry, Brian Shaw, and the roles players who had those amazing moments.
Once again in game four in the finals this year, it was Fisher, not Kobe who had that amazing moment.
In that game, I saw an interesting stat that tells it all. The thee players with the most three pointers in NBA Finals history are Michael Jordan, Kobe’s current teammate Derek Fisher, and his ex-teammate Robert Horry.
Kobe Simply Doesn’t Have The leadership Skills Required To Be One of The Greatest Ever.
There are just something’s you can’t teach. Leadership skills are one of those.
As talented as Kobe is, he simply isn’t as good of a leaders as most of the all time greats. As I was watching ESPN a few weeks back, I heard a quote similar to this that simply said it all. LeBron’s teammates want to play for him, while Kobe’s teammates don’t seem to want to.
While Lebron gets the most out of his less talented Cavaliers teammates, Kobe doesn’t seem get the most out of his much more talented teammates. Granted the Lakers won the title, there were many times when they underperformed. I generally help prove that Kobe isn’t a very good leader by showing an excerpt from Curt Schilling’s post on his official blog, 38pitches.com, after Game Two of the NBA Finals last year.
I, myself, can say what I want about Kobe being a leader from watching him on TV, but in reality I don’t have the first hand experience for you to believe what I have to say. The reason I find Schilling’s post so informing is that it’s not often you get to read such a controversial post from an objective well respected athlete about a first hand experience he had. Here is the excerpt from Schilling’s blog.
“From the first tip until about 4 minutes left in the game I saw and heard this guy bitch at his teammates. Every TO he came to the bench pissed, and a few of them he went to other guys and yelled about something they weren’t doing, or something they did wrong. No dialog about “hey let’s go, let’s get after it” or whatever. He spent the better part of 3.5 quarters pissed off and ranting at the non-execution or lack of, of his team. Then when they made what almost was a historic run in the 4th, during a TO, he got down on the floor and basically said ‘Let’s f’ing go, right now, right here” or something to that affect. . . . But as a fan I was watching the whole thing, Kobe, his teammates and then the after effects of conversations. He’d yell at someone, make a point, or send a message, turn and walk away, and more than once the person on the other end would roll eyes or give a ‘whatever dude’ look.
Now it’s very important to realize again what overrated means. Like I said before, Overrated means that people perceive you to be better than you are. If you talk to the average NBA fan and even some of the so called “experts” as well, many of them will believe things that simply are illogical.
There are those people who believe Kobe is as good or better than Jordan. There is an also even higher percentage of people who believe that Kobe led the Lakers to the title and not Shaq, or that they both had equal roles.
There are also people who believe that career wise, Kobe, a man with one finals MVP, is better career wise than three times finals MVP’s Shaq and Tim Duncan, and other all time greats. Kobe hasn’t done enough yet to prove that he belongs in that same company yet.
Right now as it stands Kobe has led one incredibly talented team to a championship.
Therefore, before we put him up there with Chamberlain, Shaq, Jordan, and the rest of those guys, let’s see what he does in the next few years.
In any defense, the tackles may be the most important part.
They are the first line, and they’re the tone-setters. Their play can determine the difficulty or ease of the linebackers, cornerbacks, and safeties behind them.
If the line is playing well and keep the linebackers clean, odds are that team will be fairly successful. If they’re not, their respective team is looking at a very long day.
They’re the biggest guys on the field and their only intention is to make sure that the other big guys across from them don’t move them. They growl, they snot, and they snarl just to defend that six inches of ground.
The trenches. It’s the reason why we love football and what makes it such a man’s man of a sport. Giving up or keeping that six inches can be the difference between a win and a loss.
These are the guys who do it best.
5. Mike Patterson – Philadelphia Eagles
54 games started, 9.5 sacks, 1 INT, 3 forced fumbles, 1 TD, 154 tackles
Patterson has been solid since his first days in the NFL, but over the last two seasons he has really began to separate himself as one of the better tackles in all of football.
He’s grown into a brick wall. He’s not tall, and not all that big at only 5’11 and barely breaking 300 pounds, but he understands that leverage is all that counts when you’re a lineman, and he uses it better than most.
His shorter stature seems to help with this, as it’s much easier for a guy at 5’11 to get lower than a guy at around 6’4.
Look for Patterson in the Pro Bowl this year, and several times in seasons following. If this list is put together again in a few years, he may find himself much higher.
4. Marcus Stroud – Buffalo Bills
100 games started, 24.5 sacks, 7 forced fumbles, 245 tackles, *3-time Pro Bowler
Stroud is an absolutely dominating force.
He’s highly underrated because of the small markets he’s played in (Jacksonville and Buffalo), but make no mistake there is not a single offensive coordinator in the league who doesn’t gamplan for a way around Marcus Stroud.
Even without the deserved media coverage, Stroud has still found his way to three Pro Bowls. One more than his former teammate, John Henderson.
Stroud is always going to command a double-team, and will make his teammates better because of it.
3. Tommie Harris – Chicago Bears
69 games started, 24.5 sacks, 5 forced fumbles, 143 tackles, *3-time Pro Bowler
Tommie Harris may be the quickest man playing defensive tackle.
Unlike Patterson, Harris is much more of a pass-rush specialist. While he certainly doesn’t seem to lack against the run, his forte is getting pressure on the quarterback and creating havoc in the backfield.
Barring injuries, Harris may be considered the best tackle in all of football, regardless of the scheme. Unfortunately for Harris and the Bears, he has been injured throughout his career and unable to reach his full potential.
Even while he may not ever get to that point, he is still a force to be reckoned with and should be recognized as one of the most complete tackles playing the game today.
2. Albert Haynesworth – Washington Redskins
74 games started, 24 sacks, 6 forced fumbles, 200 tackles, *2-time Pro Bowler and All-Pro
Personally, I’m not a huge fan of Albert Haynesworth. He seems to only be motivated by the money and the glory of playing professional football. I may be wrong, but the fact that he has only produced in contract years does nothing to temper the criticism.
As far as on-the-field goes, no one has been better than Haynesworth the past two years. He has been a disrupting force anywhere along the line. While he’s mainly a tackle, he has moved out to defensive end on occasion with great success.
He is a beast of a human being and is able to beat nearly any offensive lineman that the league can throw at him. Again, the only problem is that he has only produced in contract years.
If we throw out the past two seasons (both contract years), Haynesworth has a mere 9.5 sacks. He also has never finished out an entire season. This, in my mind, does not entitle him to the $100 million contract he received. He has his money, now will he be motivated to perform?
1. Kevin Williams – Minnesota Vikings
94 games started, 42.5 sacks, 4 INTs, 5 forced fumbles, 4 TDs, 223 tackles, *4-time Pro Bowler and All-Pro
Kevin Williams is without question the very best defensive tackle in the entire NFL.
He is incredibly reliable (having missed only two games in his career), and can rush the passer as well as stuff the run.
He’s an absolute wrecking ball on the line. Moving him is a nightmare for any offensive line. He consistently must be double-teamed if he is going to be taken out of a game, and even then he usually dominates.
His rare mix of being able to get to the quarterback and hold his own on the line is something the NFL hasn’t seen since back when Reggie White graced the football field with his presence.
The four career interceptions, two of which he’s returned for touchdowns, shows the rare athleticism he possesses for a man his size. He also has scooped up two fumbles for touchdowns.
Williams is a talent that only comes along once a generation. He’s a man who’s extremely underappreciated because of the position he plays, but should get serious Hall of Fame looks if his career holds up the way it is.
Part of a long tradition of great Eagles’ inside linebackers, Byron Evans, is unquestionably the most underrated Eagle at that position ever. Chuck Bednarik, Bill Bergey, Jeremiah Trotter and Stewart Bradley all deserve their high praise, but so does Evans so here it comes.
Byron should be known at least for his all-time great touchdown celebration, known as the “Beanie-Wiggle.” If you have never seen him shake his stuff, click here.
More seriously, Evans was a key member of the vaunted “Gang Green Defense” of the late ’80s and early ’90s. It was the play of the defensive line that really stole the thunder. Guys like Reggie White, Jerome Brown and Clyde Simmons are some of the greatest to ever play their positions.
Seth Joyner and William Thomas were great linebackers in that era as well but Byron Evans locked down the middle linebacker position and is deserving of more credit than he received.
Evans embodied Eagles’ football of that era and played his entire eight year career in Kelly Green, never earning a pro-bowl berth although he easily deserved a few.
His 184 tackles, three interceptions, and three fumble recoveries in 1989 seem pro-bowl caliber as does his 1992 production of 175 tackles and 4 interceptions. Plus, the guy was just fun to watch. He made great plays, had a nose for the ball and really anchored the linebackers on one of the greatest defenses in NFL history.
Evans did earn second team all-NFL honors in 1990 and 1992.
As his statistics indicate, Evans was a great tackler. Tommy Lawlor of Fan-demonium commented on his memory of Byron Evans which I thought really summed up the kind of player he was:
“The thing that pops in my mind with Evans is his long arms. I can always see him in his stance with his arms dangling … He was an outstanding wrap-up tackler, but the arms also helped in pass defense. ”
He was unquestionably a leader on the field and became the Eagles defensive signal caller in 1988 and the defensive captain the following season. Considering the defense he played for, those are pretty high accolades.
Evans told Jim Gehman of PhiladelphiaEagles.com, “To be named one of the captains, you had to trust the person and really believe in what they were doing. They believed that you were a leader and that made me feel real good.”
One of the most challenging defensive systems in NFL history was Buddy Ryan’s 46 Bear and Byron Evans was the master of the most dynamic role in the system which demonstrates his versatile athleticism and intelligence.
In a 2008 interview with Jim Gehman of PhiladelphiaEagles.com, Evans commented on Ryan’s defensive system.
“It was very complicated, probably one of the most complex defenses of all time, but it wasn’t intimidating. I think more than anything, I was surrounded by a good bunch of guys who were willing to go the extra mile and help me out and really give me the confidence boost that I needed. If I studied, I could make it happen.”
His career was unfortunately cut short in a devastating injury that occurred during a tackle of the Cleveland Brown’s bruising running back Leroy Hoard. Evans broke his leg and tore his MCL in one play. When Evans went down, it kind of felt like the end of an era to me.
For those who never experienced the gang green defense, I recall it as one of the most incredible things I can remember in Philadelphia sports history. In the middle of it all was another unsung Eagle, 6’2″ and 235 pounds of Byron Evans, one of the all-time Philadelphia Eagles’ great players.
Getting a win in Week 1 is vital, but getting a win in Week 2 can start a roll that can last deep into the season. Every season at least one team does it, and both of these teams are prime candidates to get on such a roll.
The Saints come into Philadelphia toting possibly the most explosive offense in the entire NFL, against the Eagles who boast one of the most suffocating defenses in the league over the past 10 year. Even without the late, great Jim Johnson, the Eagles defense proved they could dominate last week against the Panthers.
Both teams have a shot at this game, but here at 2M2MG, we’re Eagles homers. So let’s look at the keys to the game for the Birds, shall we?
Health of Donovan McNabb
While I believe the Eagles could beat the Saints with or without McNabb, having him makes the task much easier.
There’s not much debate regarding McNabb’s status as an elite, top five quarterback, so it’s obvious that the Eagles are a much better team with him. On the other side of that, Kevin Kolb, who would start in his absense, is unproven and in fact has done nothing but show that he is incapable rather than making a push for McNabb’s job.
Just having McNabb on the field adds a new aspect to the offense that the Saints defense must worry about, which in itself makes him a vital piece of the game. Broken rib or not, he gives this offense the best opportunity to score points.
Disrupt Drew Brees’ Timing
If the Eagles defense is going to stop the Saints high-powered offense, they’re going to have to disrupt Brees’ timing. How do they do that? They do it by blitzing, blitzing, and when all else fails, just blitz some more.
It does, however, have to be precise and well-planned blitzing or Brees will pick the defense apart. By this I mean blitzing a corner from Brees’ blindside, stunting along the line, and just simply blitzing effectively. If the blitzers are getting stone-walled, then Brees will have an easy day.
If Brees has an easy day, the Eagles will lose.
Control the Clock — Keep Brees & Co. On the Sideline
This is the simplest key to achieve, as it should be easy for Brian Westbrook and LeSean McCoy to run behind Leonard Weaver and this athletic offensive line. The Saints defense is below average and should struggle mightily against the run if the Eagles will committ to it.
This will be a key for every team facing off against the Saints this season, as the defense is obviously nothing to be worried about, but the offense can win games all by itself. Teams will certainly rather have their offense playing the same squad that gave up 27 points to the Detroit Lions rather than the quarterback those nearly beat Dan Marino’s passing yards record last season.
Reid should have Eldra Buckley active this week, as a power back would certainly go a long way in wearing down this defense even further.
Week 1 can be the most important game of the entire year for a football team. For example, Eagles fans will remember Week 1 of the 2007 season as the game that doomed the Eagles for the year, but sent the Green Bay Packers to the NFC Championship game.
Many would question how the first game could possibly have such an impact, but really it’s simple. The confidence of a big win can help you through the entire year, and adversely the hurt of losing a game that you should have won can kill a season. Were the Packers the second-best team in the NFC that year? Probably not. They overachieved because of that confidence.
It may not be the same situation for the Eagles and Panthers because both are good teams, and it probably wouldn’t be much of a surprise to see either team pull it out (although most would agree the Eagles are the better team). In that instance, it’s just the fact of getting that first win to get on a roll, so either way, Week 1 is immensely important.
With that all said, let’s look at what the Eagles must do to win this game.
Jason Peters Must Win the Battle vs. Julius Peppers
Julius Peppers is quite simply a freak of nature. At first glance, he just looks like another lanky defensive end. However, at 6’6″ and 290 pounds he’s got an incredible combination of speed and strength that the NFL hasn’t seen since the Minister of Defense, Reggie White.
Jason Peters, like Peppers, is supposed to combine the athleticism and size usually unseen in a man at his position. At 6’4″ and 330 pounds, most would expect Peters to be slow and clumsy, but instead he’s got fantastic footwork and the athleticism of a man 100 pounds lighter.
To point out the obvious — this will be an incredible matchup.
If Peters can keep Peppers away from Donovan McNabb, he should be able to tear apart the Panthers’ secondary. They’re a patchwork of average players that will not be able to cover the Eagles’ receivers if McNabb is given time to find them. If he’s not, it will be a long and difficult game for the Eagles offense.
Peters’ footwork will be the difference in this matchup. If Peters can stay in front of Peppers, he should have no problem overpowering him and keeping him away from McNabb. However, if Peters remains to be slow off the ball, Peppers will eat him alive all day.
Make the Panthers Play from Behind
The best way to do this is to keep a good pass-run ratio for the first quarter (or so) of the game. By keeping it to about 55-45%, the Eagles can score some points while also tiring out the defense. This way, when the Panthers offense gets on the field, the won’t be able to rely as heavily on the running game.
Basically the plan here is to make Jake Delhomme and the receivers beat you. With Asante Samuel on Steve Smith, and Sheldon Brown on Mushin Muhammad, that should be an incredibly difficult feat for Delhomme. He’s been a pretty decent quarterback, but he has shown that if he’s forced to play from behind he’ll crumble and throw some picks.
With Samuel looking to double his production from last season, we should be able to see some big plays from him and the rest of the defense.
Once the Eagles have a lead of at least two touchdowns, then it’s time to pound the ball. Give all three running backs some reps so there’s always a fresh runner for the Carolina “D” to chase after. Give Brian Westbrook a pitch to the outside, give LeSean McCoy a carry off-tackle, then pound it up the middle with Leonard Weaver and Eldra Buckley.
The Carolina defense will be ready to roll over by the end of the third quarter.
Eliminate Mental Mistake on Both Side of the Ball
Mental mistakes were the biggest thing for the Eagles during the preseason as silly penalties would back them up and take points off the board. All penalties are mental mistakes, but the biggest ones are procedural penalties such as false start, offsides, delay of game, illegal formation, etc.
Mental mistakes would also include plays like the lateral against the Jaguars in the third preseason game. If the ball is throw backwards, it’s live. Don’t just watch it bounce around and give up an easy six points because you’re not paying attention.
If the Eagles make those kinds of mistakes repeatedly, it could mean the difference between a win and a loss to start off the season.
Execute; Do the Little Things Properly
As I said, most would consider the Eagles to be the better team in this game. Personally, that’s the ship I’m on at the moment. If you compare the offenses, it goes to the Eagles I believe because the Panthers don’t have much of a passing game. If you compare the defenses, it’s not even an argument that the Eagles take the cake there as well.
With that said, the Eagles just need to do the little things properly and they should be able to walk away with a victory. Little things such as making your blocks even if you’re backside, and always making sure the ball is moving forward. Even if it’s only one or two yards, it’s a positive play. If you spend time going backwards, it begins to add up.
Considering it’s a Week 1 game, there’s bound to be some mistakes in execution. However, if they can keep the mistakes at a minimum, they should be 1-0 for their home opener against the Saints in Week 2.
With the first round of cuts taking place today in about 15 minutes and the final round of cuts taking place on Saturday, it’s about the right time to take a look at how the Philadelphia Eagles roster will look for the 2009-2010 season.
Earlier in the year—about two months before training camp even began—I laid out my 53 guys to make the roster. Now that the preseason is just about over (the fourth game is looming, but it’s understood that if you didn’t produce in the first three games, you’re only holding a tryout for the other 31 teams in the fourth), it’s time to take a look at the roster again.
Note: this is more an article of how the roster should look, rather than what the roster will exactly look like. Reid’s moves will be taken into consideration, however, such as Kolb staying and A.J. Feeley most likely being moved.
QB 1 – Donovan McNabb
Despite the talk about Vick, this is an obvious choice. McNabb will not lose his job this year or the next. The only way McNabb is not the quarterback of this team is if his contract runs out, or he retires.
QB 2 – Michael Vick
No matter what Reid says, Vick is the second-best quarterback on this roster. Putting him as the third-string quarterback would kill the gameday rosters and really put the Eagles in a bind if McNabb was to go down.
QB 3 – Kevin Kolb
Even though I’m not a fan of Kolb and believe A.J. Feeley should still be the third-string guy for this team, it’s just not going to happen. Kolb will be an Eagle in 2009—next season is up in the air, but for this year, he’s the third guy.
Overall: A.J. Feeley will either be cut or traded, most likely traded. I think the Eagles will carry four quarterbacks for a short while if they’re unable to move Feeley by Saturday. Look for the Eagles to expect about a fifth or sixth-round pick for Feeley.
Running Back (3)
RB 1 – Brian Westbrook
Again, not exactly a surprising option as the No. 1 guy here. Westbrook appears to be heading into this season at 100 percent and could very well have a career year if he’s able to stay healthy throughout the entire season. Many expected him to become a member of the 1,000-1,000 club—perhaps this is the year.
RB 2 – LeSean McCoy
Personally, I believe that McCoy should probably be the No. 1 guy in terms of getting more carries and playing more snaps. Doing that will keep Westbrook fresh for the playoffs and get the rookie some incredibly valuable playing time, which will help when he takes over in two years or so. His blocking will prevent that, but he should be a playmaker.
RB 3 – Eldra Buckley
Buckley has significantly outperformed Lorenzo Booker on offense and contributed on special teams. Buckley is a good third running back and a wonderful option as the second guy were Westbrook to go down for a lengthy period of time.
Overall: Lorenzo Booker has not looked bad on offense, but Buckley has just looked better. Booker should find a team, however. If Westbrook can stay healthy, this may be the best year that the Reid era has ever seen in terms of effective rushing.
FB 1 – Leonard Weaver
Weaver is a very good blocker, runner, and can also catch the ball out of the backfield. He’s the first real fullback the Eagles have had since Jon Ritchie was roaming the backfield what seems like an eternity ago. Hopefully he can be the difference-maker the Eagles expect him to be.
Overall: Kyle Eckel is a good player who could—and should—find a starting job with a team desperate for a fullback. He’s a good run-blocker, and can run the ball. He’s not great catching the ball out of the backfield, but not many teams ask that of their fullback.
Wide Receiver (6)
WR 1 – DeSean Jackson
Earlier, I had Jackson listed as the second receiver but with the way he played in camp and the way he has played in the preseason, he’s obviously the best receiver on this team. He’s making the tough catches and showing his first season—with accompanying rookie mistakes—is far behind him.
WR 2 – Kevin Curtis
This could change if Curtis is unable to get healthy, but for now he gives the Eagles a great option either stretching the defense deep or getting some yards after the catch on a simple slant or dig pattern. Hopefully he can get to 100 percent before the season and get back to 2007 form.
WR 3 – Jason Avant
Avant is certainly coming into his own as the slot receiver. He is able to go up after the ball, and may have a pair of the strongest hands in the entire league. He’s very good at extending and snagging the ball out of the air and going across the middle, something you like to see in a slot receiver.
WR 4 – Jeremy Maclin
This will of course depend on how much of the playbook he has perfected by the time the season begins, but if he can get the plays down he will be the fourth receiver. Given the “receiver-by-committee” approach the Eagles use, the fourth receiver still sees plenty of playing time. Hopefully Maclin is up to it and moves up the depth chart throughout the season.
WR 5 – Reggie Brown
Yes, that’s right. Reggie Brown. Word is there’s not much interest for Brown as far as a trade goes, so he will be the guy to stay. The lack of interest is probably not as much about a perceived lack of talent as it is a fairly big contract for a fifth receiver, and the fact that he has been a bit injury-prone over the past couple of seasons.
WR 6 – Brandon Gibson
Gibson is a guy who I wished could stay since day one, and his training camp/preseason has done nothing to make me think otherwise. In fact, I like him even more. He’s a smart guy who uses his physical abilities to put himself in position to make the catch. He will be a playmaker in this league one day, hopefully very soon.
Overall: Hank Baskett will more than likely wind up getting traded. Word is that their is some interest but that the offers have not “blown the Eagles away.” A fourth-round pick would probably blow them away, but they may have to settle for a conditional sixth, or at most a fifth-round pick for Baskett.
Tight End (3)
TE 1 – Brent Celek
By allowing L.J. Smith to leave via free agency, the Eagles were making Celek the No. 1 by default. He showed up huge in the NFC Championship game and should be able to continue that success into the 2009 season. Look for Celek to be a favorite target for McNabb in the redzone.
TE 2 – Rob Myers
The rookie free agent, who is only getting a shot on this team because of the injury to Cornelius Ingram, is certainly making the most of it by showing some speed and good hands. He proved a surprise this offseason, and hopefully can keep surprising into the season.
TE 3 – Matt Schobel
Much like you, the reader, I’m not a fan of Matt Schobel. He has good hands, but unfortunately he can’t get off the line or get open long enough to be able to use those hands. However, even with the signing of Tony Curtis, Schobel will probably be the choice here because he knows the offense and the Eagles would like a veteran presence around for a rookie and a first-year starter.
Overall: While Tony Curtis is the best choice for the third tight end position, he doesn’t know the Eagles’ offense and came in rather late. He could still make the team in place of Schobel—and my hope is he will—but at this point I don’t see it happening. Eugene Bright is still on the team, but he hasn’t shown enough to warrant a place on the final roster. Maybe a practice squad guy.
Offensive Line (9)
LT 1 – Jason Peters
The Eagles traded for Peters this offseason so he could come in and be the team’s starting left tackle, and that’s just what he’s going to do. He’s had some issues in the preseason with his speed off the line and picking up blitzes, so we’ll just have to wait and see how he does.
LG 1 – Todd Herremans
Herremans will be the guy when he returns from foot surgery. So, technically, he’s the No. 1 left guard heading into the season. He made some strides during training camp, so it was a real setback when he was hit with this injury. He should, however, be able to make a full recovery and be just fine after missing about two or three games.
C 1 – Jamaal Jackson
Many people have been calling for a demotion for Jackson, but the fact is he’s the best center on this roster by a long shot. He knows how to put his guys into position, and is a big reason why the Eagles can shuffle their offensive linemen in and out (because of injuries) and still be successful. In short, he does a whole lot more than you’d think.
RG 1 – Stacy Andrews
Stacy has been impressive when he’s been able to line up and play. He’s at 100 percent right now, and isn’t a health concern heading into the season. He won’t play this week, so he’ll have plenty of time to rest up and prepare for Week One against Carolina.
RT 1 – Shawn Andrews
To hear that Shawn was back at practice and feeling good may have been the best news of the entire preseason. With him on the field, the offensive line is just a different unit. He adds an attitude to the line that is incredible to watch. Let’s also not forget that as far as pure talent goes, he’s one of the best in the league.
LT 1 – King Dunlap
A seventh-round pick a year ago, Dunlap has stuck on with the Eagles because of his athleticism and potential. However, he won’t be an Eagle much longer if he can’t keep his weight under control, which—oddly enough for a linemen—is too low, and be able to use his feet better in pass protection. For now, he’s a project worth keeping.
LG 2 – Max Jean-Gilles
The former fourth-round pick has slimmed down a bit and increased his athleticism so he could become the linemen the Eagles wanted him to be. The loss of weight will help his ankle problems and should help him be a better pass protector. He’s a road-grater and a great guy to run behind, so that’s not a problem. He’ll probably get the start until Herremans is healthy.
C/RG 2 – Nick Cole
Cole, on most other teams in the NFL, is a borderline starter at right guard and a serviceable backup at center. Versatility is something that Andy Reid loves, and loves is so much he requires it of his linemen. Cole brings that and will keep a spot on this team because of it.
RT 2 – Winston Justice
Justice has picked up his play so much it’s really incredible to watch. Seeing him play during training camp was like watching a different guy. He’s not the same puppy he was when Hugh Douglas called him out a couple years back. This guy has realized it’s time to pick up his game, and could be a starter if Shawn Andrews is not ready for the season.
Overall: Mike Gibson, Mike McGlynn, and Fenuki Tupou are all guys the Eagles would like to keep, but unfortunately some of them are destined for the practice squad as they lose a numbers game.
Defensive Line (10)
RE 1 – Trent Cole
Cole is a top-flight NFL talent, so it’s obvious he would be the starter at right end. Hopefully, Cole can get some more help from the rotation at left end in order to get him some more sacks. Even without a whole lot of help, he’s put himself into the elite for defensive ends.
DT 1 – Brodrick Bunkley
Bunkley has become a dominant run-stuffing defensive tackle, but he can also get after the quarterback on occasion. He put on some weight in order to become the space-eater he is, but still has held on to the athleticism he had at Florida State that caused the Eagles to draft him with the 14th overall pick in 2006.
DT 2 – Mike Patterson
Another former first-round pick, Patterson has really stepped up his game. After being a good starter for a couple years, Patterson is now a guy who is expected to make the Pro Bowl this year after getting snubbed last year. Like Bunkley, he’s a space-eater with the ability to get to the quarterback.
LE 1 – Juqua Parker
The Eagles wanted the job to go to Victor Abiamiri, but with his injury it’s not going to happen this year. Parker will be the starter for Week One and beyond, but—if Abiamiri outplays him—Sean McDermott certainly wouldn’t hesitate to start Abiamiri. Parker has done well at starting fast, but then he disappears after Week Eight. If he can finish strong as well, the Eagles are in good shape.
RE 2 – Jason Babin
Babin has gone from an outcast first-round pick to Trent Cole’s backup on the right side. Usually, a first-round pick being a backup isn’t a good thing. However, when you can pick that first-round pick up off the scrap heap and put him behind one the best ends in the league, you’ve got yourself a good deal.
DT 3 – Trevor Laws
The second-round pick from last year (picked two spots before DeSean Jackson) didn’t get a whole lot of playing time, so it’s difficult to judge where he’s at in his NFL career. He also spent a good portion of training camp with the training staff, so he may not be counted on too much this year either.
LE 2 – Victor Abiamiri
To this point, Abiamiri has been a disappointment. A second-round pick is supposed to contribute a lot more than what he has produced to this point. Injury after injury has hampered his progress, but even with the injuries he probably only has this season and the next to show he has what it takes to keep him around.
RE 3 – Bryan Smith
The former third-round pick probably doesn’t belong on this team. He didn’t suit up for a single game last season and hasn’t shown much progress this year, but given that he’s a third-round pick Reid will probably keep him on board one more season to see if he has any surprises.
LE 3 – Chris Clemons
To put Clemons on one side or the other—or to call him the third guy—is probably a bit deceiving. He will play much more than a normal third-string guy would, as he’ll be called upon in passing situations to get after the quarterback on whichever side McDermott needs him to play.
LE/RE/DT 4 – Darren Howard
It’s difficult to give Howard a position or a number depth-wise. He’s all over the line, literally playing everywhere. He would come in before guys like Clemons and Smith, but may also come in before Trevor Laws at defensive tackle. Howard is incredibly important to this team, and—no matter where you list him—he’s going to be an Eagle.
Overall: If the Eagles pull a surprise move and cut Bryan Smith, it will only be so that they can keep Dan Klecko as the fourth defensive tackle. However, because of Howard’s versatility, the fan-favorite Klecko could be on his way out.
SAM 1 – Chris Gocong
Personally, I don’t believe Gocong has progressed the way he should have at this point in his career. He still can’t cover a tight end to save his life and just doesn’t make enough big plays to be a starting linebacker for this team. He may never be any better than this, and if that’s the case then it’s time for the Eagles to look elsewhere. Let’s hope I’m wrong.
MIKE 1 – Omar Gaither
Gaither showed some ability in 2007, and it should lead to a successful stopgap for 2009 until Stewart Bradley can come back in 2010 from a torn ACL. Gaither isn’t the prototypical middle linebacker, but it’s the position he wants to play, and he’s certainly intelligent enough to do it. Players see him as a leader and he embraces the role.
WILL 1 – Akeem Jordan
Jordan is fast and good at shedding blocks. However, he needs to focus on tackling and reading an offense better in his first full season as a starter. If he can do that, he could quickly be in talks for a Pro Bowl bid. The physical ability is there, so if he can tie-in the mental aspect of it he should have a very bright NFL career.
SAM 2 – Moise Fukou
The seventh-round pick was an afterthought without much of a chance to make the team, but now is looking at becoming the primary backup at all three positions. He’s gotten some reps at MIKE and looked pretty good during them, but he’s young and not ready to “drive the car,” as Omar Gaither put it.
MIKE 2 – Joe Mays
Mays was supposed to be the starter entering the year, but a poor preseason has doomed him to backup yet again as Omar Gaither looks to take the starting role for the Birds. If he can pick up the defense a little better to the point he doesn’t need to think as much, he may be able to supplant Gaither at some point. It will be a continuing battle.
WILL 2 – Tracy White
White makes the team because of his contributions to special teams, but if Akeem Jordan were to go down there would probably be a shuffling of linebackers to take over the spot rather than making White the starter. Perhaps a move for Gaither to WILL and Mays would step in at MIKE.
Overall: Matt Wilhelm is the wild card here. If he can play WILL he might take White’s spot, but if he can’t then I don’t forsee him getting a spot on this roster. The Eagles are already cutting it close, so Wilhelm will have to really show something in the final preseason game.
Defensive Backs (9)
CB 1 – Asante Samuel
Outside of Nnamdi Asomugha and possibly Champ Bailey, Samuel is the best cornerback in the league. He’s a ballhawk and should be able to top his six interceptions (including postseason) from last year with another year in this defense under his belt.
CB 2 – Sheldon Brown
Brown may be unhappy with his contract, but he’s a professional and has acted as such. He’s not whining and crying like many other players will do, instead showing up to practice, do his job, and not let his personal issues with the front office affect his relationship with the players or in the lockerroom. He’s the obvious No. 2 option.
*SS 1 – Quintin Mikell
Mikell made some All-Pro teams last season, but got snubbed for the Pro Bowl. He’s shown that his time under Brian Dawkins has really paid off as he’s made his mark as one of the hardest hitters in the league at the safety position. He can also make some good plays in the passing game and should get his first Pro Bowl nod this season.
FS 1 – Sean Jones
Demps has been the starter, but Reid said the competition for the free safety spot will extend into the fourth preseason game. Jones just needs to make a couple plays and he’ll have the starting spot wrapped up. The Eagles obviously don’t have faith in Demps for this year any longer, so Jones should be able to step right in.
FS 2 – Quintin Demps
Demps is a good backup and will probably return kicks as well, but if you’re familiar with my writings, you’ll know that I’m not a fan of Demps as a starter—at least for right now, and perhaps ever. He’ll have to show that he’s not afraid of contact first.
FS 3 – Victor “Macho” Harris
Harris is a ‘tweener as either a safety or a corner, so the Eagles will probably utilize him as a backup as both positions. He should be a good safety one day, and the Eagles are excited at the prospect of seeing Harris grow into that role.
*Note: The reason that there is no backup for strong safety is because in the event Quintin Mikell were to go down, the Eagles would slide Sean Jones over to strong, and play Demps at free. Macho Harris would then become the backup at both spots.
CB 3 – Ellis Hobbs
Hobbs was traded from New England because he was unhappy about his contract, but now all he has is the same contract in a different city—and a demotion on top of everything else. I’m sure he’s not happy about his role as the team’s nickel corner, but as such he gives the Eagles the best nickel corner in the league.
CB 4 – Joselio Hanson
A shiny new 4-year $20 million contract for your dime corner? Well, it’s only because they don’t anticipate him being a dime corner past this season. Hobbs is more than likely going to walk after the season for a starting job, and Hanson will resume his duties as nickel corner. Until then, there’s not a fourth receiver in the league that Hanson can’t cover.
CB 5 — Dimitri Patterson
Patterson has been incredibly physical during his time with the Eagles, and has gone from long-shot to the probable fifth corner. He’s a guy who’s not afraid to hit anyone, whether it be a receiver, running back, quarterback, or even scrap with an offensive lineman. He’s oddly reminiscent of Al Harris during his time in Philadelphia.
Overall: Jack Ikegwuonu has just not shown enough to warrant a spot on this team. Once thought of as the steal of the draft, he has not been able to regain his speed after tearing his ACL, which is evident watching receviers run away from—and around—him all preseason and training camp. The Eagles may not keep a fifth corner if they decide to keep 10 offensive linemen.
K 1 – David Akers
P 1 – Sav Rocca
LS 1 – Jon Dorenbos
Overall: No surprises here. The only competition for the three was Ken Parrish as a kicker/punter, but he was cut in order to bring in Rob Myers.
As it stands, the Eagles may have one of the better receiving corps in the NFC. They don’t have that standout guy just yet, even though it appears DeSean Jackson may become that guy, but as far as talent and depth goes, they’re certainly at the very top.
If they had an opportunity to improve the receiving corp, however, it would be irresponsible not to take every advantage of that opportunity. Teams, regardless how they feel about their current roster, are always looking for ways to improve. For the Eagles, Brandon Marshall would certainly provide an improvement.
So, what would it take to get the deal done? Not a whole lot from where the Eagles are sitting, but they could get a whole lot in return.
Currently, the Broncos are not happy with their position at quarterback. Kyle Orton has not looked like the same quarterback that he was in Chicago, and Chris Simms is currently injured and watching from the bench, anyway. Add in the fact that now Orton is banged up and questionable for Week 1, and you’ve got a mess in Mile High.
Per Adam Schefter:
“Denver could have a problem if Kyle Orton‘s finger injury keeps him out of the regular-season opener against Cincinnati. Those who know Chris Simms, Denver’s backup quarterback, do not believe he will be ready to play the Broncos opener and think his high ankle sprain will sideline him closer to a month. At least.”
This is an area in which the Eagles can help.
Realistically, A.J. Feeley has been on the trading block since the day Vick was signed. McNabb is firmly entrenched as the starter, Kevin Kolb was a second round pick and isn’t going anywhere, and Michael Vick has no trade value. If the Broncos wanted him, they could have signed him.
Feeley has shown that he has the talent and the poise to lead a team, as he has done with the Eagles. Josh McDaniels got to see Feeley up close and personal in 2007 as the Patriots’ offensive coordinator when Feeley passed for nearly 350 yards and three touchdowns to come just three points shy of ending the Pats perfect run.
Word out of New England is that even Bill Belichick is interested in Feeley. If McDaniels is anything like Belichick, which years of tutelage would cause one to think that he is, then he must have an interest in Feeley too. In fact, the Broncos are a team that has been linked to interest in Feeley recently. Whether or not that’s because of McDaniels is neither here nor there.
The Broncos, who have said they won’t trade Marshall, have seemingly contradicted themselves by allowing it to be known that they are in fact looking for help at receiver. This would seem to indicate that they are anticipating a vacancy at the position and, again, the Eagles can help.
The Eagles would most likely be willing to part ways with Kevin Curtis, Hank Baskett, and Reggie Brown. Baskett and Brown are on the chop block, while Curtis may find himself on the trading block if they get an interesting offer. With Marshall’s spot becoming open and Jabar Gaffney’s broken thumb, the Broncos just may interested in two of those three.
If I’m the Eagles, it makes sense to call the Broncos and offer them A.J. Feeley, Kevin Curtis, and Reggie Brown for Marshall. If they don’t want to take that offer (which they probably wouldn’t), then simply throw in Hank Baskett and perhaps a late-round draft pick — maybe a conditional fourth depending on Marshall’s production and Baskett, Brown, and Curtis’ playing time.
All three receivers may be a bit steep, but considering that either Baskett or Brown will be gone sometime this week anyway, and the fact that Marshall would be stepping in, it looks a whole lot better from the Eagles’ perspective. If the trade were to go down, their receiving corps would look something like this:
1. Brandon Marshall
2. DeSean Jackson
3. Jason Avant
4. Jeremy Maclin
5. Brandon Gibson
Then, if they really wanted to, there are guys like Matt Jones floating around in free agency that could make for a fantastic sixth receiver.
For the Broncos, this may seem like a raw deal, but they’re in a tough spot, and would be filling some needs.
A.J. Feeley could come in and start for them until Orton was ready, or even start for the entire year if he plays well, which isn’t stretch. Even if Orton supplants Feeley at some point, Feeley gives you one of the best backup quarterbacks in the league.
Then, their receiving corps would look a little something like this:
1. Eddie Royal
2. Kevin Curtis
3. Brandon Stokley
4. Reggie Brown
5. Hank Baskett
6. Chad Jackson/Brandon Lloyd
With Feeley gunning it around to that group of guys, the offense could see some success. Especially taking into account the fact that they should see great production out of Knowshon Moreno and former Eagle Correll Buckhalter in the running game.
Not only that, but it would appear as though Marshall has worn out his welcome in Denver, and that the fanbase as well as management are tired of hearing from him.
Some may say they don’t want Marshall because of his off-the-field problems, but I feel with a change of scenery and a new contract that the Eagles could certainly afford, he would be a model citizen knowing he’s with a team considered a Super Bowl contender, and in an offense that would give him a lot of opportunities to make big plays.
For the Eagles, they have the firepower, but do they want Marshall? It wouldn’t make much sense not to want Marshall, considering this is the same team that brought Michael Vick in with open arms.
For the Broncos, the trade offer may be attractive, but do they really want to trade a Pro Bowl quarterback and wide receiver all in the same offseason? Probably not, but is it really worth holding on to a receiver that doesn’t want to be there and has shown he’ll do whatever it takes to get out of town?
It would be difficult for both teams, and by no means am I saying this will happen, but the possibility is certainly there. If the Broncos management and coaching staff see Feeley as a starter until they can draft a guy, this deal could get done and done more quickly than you’d think.
When the New England Patriots cut former third-round pick, quarterback Kevin O’Connell, no one in Philadelphia paid much attention. However, that may have been a mistake.
According to Jason La Canfora of NFL Network, the Patriots are “among the many teams” interested in acquiring the services of A.J. Feeley. Back in 2007, Feeley ran the then-undefeated Patriots to the wire in a three-point loss in which he passed for nearly 350 yards, but a late interception to current teammate Asante Samuel sealed the deal.
Belichick is always looking to bring in players who have played well against his team, as evidenced by the trade for Greg Lewis earlier in the offseason. For the record, Lewis has eight touchdowns against the Patriots, including one in the Super Bowl.
As expected, La Canfora also states the obvious by saying that the Eagles will not consider moving Feeley until Vick is officially reinstated. Considering Vick will, at the very latest, be reinstated before the trading deadline, it appears as though Feeley will indeed be moving at some point in the year.
Unless a team outbids them (which is unlikely because when Belichick wants a guy, he gets a guy), Feeley will most likely be a New England Patriot.
Feeley has started in this league, and in the right system, has played very well. Personally, I’d prefer that the Eagles keep him instead of Kolb, but seeing as how Kolb was a second-round pick, he won’t be going anywhere this offseason.
Any other year, a preseason game between the Philadelphia Eagles and Jacksonville Jaguars would not have a significant impact for the fans.
However, last night’s matchup may have been one of the most hyped-up preseason games fans have seen in years since Michael Vick was making his debut with the Eagles after spending 18 months in prison for his involvement with running a dogfighting operation.
Vick’s first game back since Dec. 31, 2006 was the complete opposite of what most people expected—which may have been a great thing.
There were protesters outside of the stadium before the game, but not nearly the amount everyone expected. There were plenty of fans wearing No. 7 jerseys—even though some said “Garcia” on the back—to show their support for Vick and welcome him to the City of Brotherly Love.
Instead of a stadium divided about how they felt about Vick between cheers and boos, he received a standing ovation from fans as he made his first appearance on the field during the second play of offense for the Eagles.
Even though he was only on the field for six plays, Vick was still the man of the hour at Lincoln Financial Field. Each play, fans would anxiously wait in their seats to see if No. 7 was making his way from the sidelines to the center of the field in hope of seeing an exciting play that so many of us are used to seeing from Vick.
He may have only completed four passes for 19 yards, but it was all the Eagles needed from Vick considering he hasn’t played in the NFL for two years.
Overall, Vick had a successful return with the Eagles and did everything he was asked to do to help the Eagles win the game.
Even though the night seemed to be focused on Vick’s return, there was still a football game to be played between the Eagles and Jaguars. Even though the Eagles ended up winning 33-32, the team still has a lot to work on—both on offense and defense—if they look to be contenders in the 2009 season.
Quarterback Donovan McNabb finished 21-for-36, throwing for 244 yards and one touchdown as he played most of the first three quarters. However, he managed two key turnovers that could have resulted in points for the Eagles (he threw one backwards pass while on the Jaguars’ one-yard line that resulted into a fumble that was returned for a touchdown).
At one point, a group of Philadelphia fans began the “We Want Vick” chant after watching McNabb struggle at certain points during the game. Despite his struggles, it’s hard to blame McNabb for his performance when the entire offense looked inconsistent most of the game.
If the Eagles want to effectively use both Vick and McNabb in the upcoming 2009 season, head coach Andy Reid needs to figure out a system that will work well for everyone, especially McNabb.
In the game against the Jaguars, Reid used Vick for random plays instead of allowing him to play an entire series on his own.
There were numerous cases where McNabb would appear to get into a rhythm on offense, only to be sidelined so Vick could step in. When McNabb would return to the field for the next play, his rhythm seemed to be off again and the Eagles offense would look horrendous.
Using McNabb and Vick on offense has a lot of potential for the 2009 season, and it could confuse opposing defenses on what to expect from the Eagles each week.
However, Reid needs to figure out an effective system that will work well and keep everyone in rhythm if the Eagles want to take advantage of using Vick for the upcoming season.
Otherwise, the Eagles offense will be in for a long 2009 season, especially if they play the way they did in the first half of last night’s game.